Visit Your Local PBS Station PBS Home PBS Home Programs A-Z TV Schedules Support PBS Shop PBS Search PBS

   
the Online NewsHour
E-mail This Page Print This Page
the Online NewsHourFUNDED IN PART BYPacific LifeChevronCorporation for Public Broadcasting2
BROWSE BY
REGION
TOPIC
RECENT PROGRAMSLOCAL TV LISTINGSSUBSCRIPTIONSNEWS FOR STUDENTSSEARCH


REGION: Asia
TOPIC: International Organizations
Online NewsHour
IN-DEPTH COVERAGE
China Prepares for Olympics
BACKGROUND REPORT Posted: May 16, 2008     
Tibet Tests China's Movement on Human Rights

When China bested four other finalists to host the 2008 Summer Olympics, the win brought a new global status but also renewed scrutiny on its handling of free speech and human rights, particularly in the area of Tibet.

Protesters in TibetWhile Beijing was building its sports arenas, training its volunteer corps and setting new rules for its citizens' behavior during the Olympics -- no spitting, don't cut in line -- the long-standing issue of its governance of Tibet bubbled to the surface.

March 10 marked the 49th anniversary of a failed Tibetan protest against Chinese rule in 1959, after which the Dalai Lama left the country. Streams of Buddhist monks marked the anniversary by marching in the streets of the Tibetan capital, Lhasa.

Anti-Chinese protesters smashed vehicles and burned shops -- particularly Chinese-owned ones. That touched off violent clashes with police that lasted for several days. Authorities said 16 people died in the violence and more than 300 were injured, the Associated Press reported.

Chinese Prime Minister Wen Jiabao put the blame squarely on the Dalai Lama, the exiled Tibetan spiritual leader, and his supporters, saying they wanted to cause chaos ahead of the Olympics.

"We have ample facts and plenty of evidence that the incident was organized, masterminded and incited by the Dalai Lama clique," the premier said. "The protesters want to incite a sabotage on the Olympics in order to achieve their unspeakable goal."

But the Dalai Lama denied the accusations, saying, "China's prime minister accused me [of] all these things I started. Absolutely not. If prime minister come here and investigate thoroughly all our files, all record [of] my speech, the prime minister will know. That prime minister knows how much this [was] started by local officials."

The Chinese government dispatched hundreds of paramilitary police to patrol the region's streets to quell the violence. Officials urged tourists to stay away from the western Gansu and Sichuan provinces, where most of the clashes occurred, and banned reporters from the area.

After the protests, Chinese Foreign Ministry spokeswoman Jiang Yu defended the state of Chinese-Tibetan relations at an April 10 press conference, "The Chinese government is committed to the protection and promotion of human rights of Chinese people of all ethnic groups. Thanks to the preferential policies by the central government, Tibet has enjoyed rapid economic and social development. The culture is well-protected there, and the Tibetan people's freedom of religious belief is also fully safeguarded by law."

She also emphasized that the situation in Tibet was an internal affair, which reflects China's long-held stance that countries' sovereignty should be respected. "We hope the international community can respect and understand the solemn position of the Chinese government and people. I would like to stress that Tibet affairs are China's internal affairs, and any foreign government or organization has no right to interfere with (them)."

Dalai LamaFollowing offers from the Dalai Lama and intense international pressure, the Chinese government in late April agreed to hold talks with aides to the spiritual leader, the official Xinhua News Agency quoted unnamed government officials as saying. International leaders said they were encouraged by the reports.

The way the Chinese government handled the protests in Tibet had a direct connection to the Olympic Games, said Minxin Pei, senior associate in the China Program at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace.

"China took very effective, though widely criticized, measures to quell the unrest in Tibet, in large part because China wants to ensure that the country will be politically stable on the eve of the Olympics," he said. "It wanted to end the unrest speedily -- otherwise, Tibet will be a festering problem that may ruin the Olympics."

"Of course, Beijing has resumed dialogue with the Dalai Lama recently because it responded to international pressure. China understands that showing flexibility on the Tibetan issue after the unrest there will help quell the call for boycotting the games or its opening ceremony," Pei said.

Calvin Chen, an assistant professor of politics at Mount Holyoke College, said the Chinese government showed unusual restraint in its handling of the protests.

"When the first riots broke out in Lhasa, there were Hong Kong reporters who had very extended video clips. What they showed -- and their commentary was -- that 'there are no cops around! Why are they so restrained?'" he noted.

The government "did not want to be repressive and remind people of June 4th, 1989, when the tanks moved into Tiananmen Square. They were trying to be restrained, but then it got out of control and they had to send in the officers," he said.

When the Olympic torch relay began this spring, another dynamic came to light. The torch run incited pro-Tibet and anti-China protests, who interrupted the relay through several European cities and San Francisco and grabbed news headlines in the process. Pro-Chinese demonstrators, however, also lined the routes to show their nationalism.

As more foreign press enter the country in the lead up to the Olympics, China's message on Tibet has become harder to manage. During a government-guided press tour of a monastery, after foreigners were allowed back into Tibet, a group of monks gathered in front of the tour. They countered the government line that the exiled Dalai Lama had incited the earlier riots and complained about China's oppressive rule, before police intervened and separated them from the journalists.

"We were all surprised by that," recalled Chen. "The past pattern has been to say, 'OK, we're going to take you into, say, a monastery, and you see the monks, everybody's really happy.' ... So it really was a surprise to all of us to see that. It was very unusual, so I would say it doesn't fit their past pattern at all."

Herbert London, president of the Hudson Institute, explained: "Apparently, this was vetted beforehand and they thought they had some monks who would certainly provide very positive statements about what is going on in China vis-a-vis Tibet, but that did not happen. ... It certainly conveyed a very different impression, a very honest impression, of what is going on."

Chinese police in TibetTo London, the incident was an example of the government's struggle to let in observers while still casting events in a positive light. "There are two things that are going on. One is, obviously, there is a crackdown that's occurring; it's not only occurring in Tibet. ... There is also an attempt to put a gloss over this, to create the impression that things are really quite satisfactory, that people do have civil rights, and so you will have what I've described before as a kind of Potemkin village in China, where they will try and put the best possible face they can on the Olympics."

The Chinese government has countered that activists are using the attention from the Olympics to try to tarnish China's image. Foreign Minister Yang Jiechi said party leaders welcome suggestions and "criticism out of good will," according to the state news agency Xinhua.

Some of China's reaction to the Tibet protests also has historic roots. In the 19th century, China went from the premier regional power to a colonial asset. This treatment at the hands of the West remains fresh in the minds of many Chinese, and is likely the biggest reason the government has flatly refused to consider giving up Tibet, especially at the behest of Western protests, explained Vera Schwarcz, chairwoman of the East Asian Studies Program at Wesleyan University.

"If you look at China through history with disunity and imperialism and war into the 20th century, the ideal of symbolic unity of China is so important to so many people," said Schwarcz. "When Mao took power, in 1949, October 1st, he stood in Tiananmen Square, in his very thick Henanese accent, he didn't say 'The Communist Party won,' like the Bolsheviks did in the Soviet Union. He said, 'The Chinese people have stood up.'

"This is a people -- not just a party, but a people -- that sees itself as kneeling, forced to kneel in front of the world and [it is] eager to get off its knees," she said.


-- By Peter Seabrook, Online NewsHour

ADDITIONAL FEATURES
  Main: China Prepares for Olympics
Resources
  Interactive: Compare Life in
  Olympic Host Cities
  Slide Show: Olympic Stadiums
  Around the Globe
  Archive
For Students and Teachers
  Lesson Plan
  Politics and the Olympics
  Student Voice
  Returning to China
ALSO ON THE NEWSHOUR
Paul Solman Reports:
China on the Rise
Chinese flag Paul Solman traveled to China in 2005 to report on the nation as a growing economic contender.
Slide Show: Nixon's 1972 Historic Trip to China
China President Nixon's visit to China in 1972 paved the way to normalizing diplomatic relations.
Frontline: China in the Red
China Frontline tells the story of 10 Chinese individuals caught up in the country's efforts to modernize.
ABOUT US | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS / FEEDS: 
POD|RSS
Funded, in part, by:Pacific LifeChevronCorporation for Public Broadcasting
            Support the kind of journalism done by the NewsHour...Become a member of your local PBS station.
PBS Online Privacy Policy

Copyright ©1996- MacNeil/Lehrer Productions. All Rights Reserved.